An angel helps a compassionate but despairingly frustrated businessman by showing what life would have been like if he never existed.
My good friend Austin from The Bishop Review is currently running a project called Classic Movie Week, where 7 different bloggers are taking on 7 different classic, black and white movies. I was honoured to be asked to join his project, and figured I would review something from the IMDB Top 250 (2 birds, 1 stone and all that!) Here are my thoughts then on the classic movie It’s A Wonderful Life, and you can find my post on Austin’s site HERE, so you can check it out twice!
Top 250 #30
Year of Release: 1946
Director: Frank Capra
Cast:
James Stewart – George Bailey
Donna Reed – Mary Hatch
Lionel Barrymore – Henry F. Potter
Thomas Mitchell – Uncle Billy Bailey
Henry Travers – Clarence
There are some films that people only ever say good things about. Quite simply, they are considered ‘classics‘ or ‘masterpieces‘. I’m not a huge fan of labelling films with those terms, simply because everyone’s opinion is subjective, and those terms can get thrown around all too easily. Yet when talking about something like It’s A Wonderful Life, it’s pretty much impossible not to go along with the general consensus and call this movie one of those superlatives. It is just a beautiful picture with a relatively simple story, yet is timeless and an absolute joy to watch.
Some people are brought up on these old classics. Others find their own way to them, normally through their parents or from looking at ‘greatest of all time‘ lists. For me, well anyone who has read my ‘about me‘ page will know how my love affair with films started. It’s safe to say it wasn’t because of these beautiful black and white films. I have basically caught up with this golden generation a long time after everyone else. I’m very slowly working through what most people would call classics, and so when Austin asked me about joining his project, I knew It’s A Wonderful Life was the perfect choice for me.
I presume most people will know the plot, but I’ll just cover it very briefly. Released in 1946, the film stars James Stewart as George Bailey, a man who has given up his dreams in order to help others, and whose imminent suicide on Christmas Eve brings about the intervention of his guardian angel, Clarence Odbody (Henry Travers). Clarence shows George all the lives he has touched and how different life in his community would be had he never been born.
Right from the beginning, when George risks his own life to save the life of his younger brother Harry, who had fallen through the ice on a frozen pond, and because of his heroic action, George lost the hearing in his left ear, we see what a kind, amazing person George is. This never changes, he saves a man from poisoning a child, he repeatedly sacrifices his dream to travel the world, he gives away his honeymoon money. It goes on, just a man doing kind things, and eventually it all gets too much for him, and after a series of unfortunate events, he can’t go on the trips as he has always wanted and he has to look after the family business – the bank. George gets tied down with a family and feels trapped in a world in which he doesn’t want to belong, and he then realises he is worth more dead than alive. The intervention from his guardian angel then shows George what the town would have been like without him. Bedford Falls, named Pottersville, is home to sleazy nightclubs and pawn shops. Bailey Park is never built. Mr. Gower was sent to prison for poisoning the child and is a despised derelict.
But most importantly for George, who has four children with the beautiful Mary (Donna Reed) in his real life, he sees Mary as a single spinster librarian. Rushing back to the bridge and begging for his life back, the film finishes with one of the most beautiful endings I have ever seen, as George realizes that he truly has a wonderful life. Perfect, and no wonder this is a film loved by so many people.
Tony Soprano (James Gandolfini’s character in the greatest TV show of all time, The Sopranos) used to mention Jimmy Stewart on the show. He wished everyone was more like Stewart, and you know what, maybe he was right. I’ve seen Stewart in Rear Window, and Vertigo, but I don’t think he has ever been better than he is in Wonderful Life. I can’t believe he was beaten to the Oscar. He showcases everything here. From being a loving, kind, caring person, to when he eventually loses it and trashes the house, Stewart is incredible to watch and I couldn’t take my eyes off him. Equally, his wife, Donna Reed, is so sweet, and absolutely beautiful to look at. She is definitely not just a token wife. She is a strong and kind woman, who dearly wants to see her husband happy. Even Lionel Barrymore as the cold, Scrooge-like Mr. Potter owns every scene he is in. Whilst everyone takes a back seat to Stewart here, It’s A Wonderful Life is filled with excellent characters that bring both humour and sadness into the story. Every range of emotion is on show; envy, love, corruption, joy, hope, faith and despair, all beautifully portrayed by the actors. We even get a nice moral to end the story with. Something that is sadly lacking these days in films.
Frank Capra’s directing is masterful, and it’s easy to see why both he and Stewart class this film as their personal favourite. I know there is a re-mastered version in colour now, but this film has to be seen in black and white. It is quite simply beautiful, and most people consider it the essential Christmas time film. No one should underestimate the power of its themes, themes that are ageless and universal. It just reminds us of how we can all make a difference to others. And what a sweet way to show us!
I can’t really say much more, as I’m sure everything that can be said about It’s A Wonderful Life has already been said by much better writers than me. I just hope my little opinion on the movie does it justice, and whereas most of the time I’m trying to point you all in the direction of something more obscure, I’m guessing most of you have seen this classic, and I hope you all loved it as much as I did.
le0pard13
/ January 25, 2013Few things touch me like this film. Fine look at this, Tyson.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013Thanks Michael, appreciate it. Such a beautiful, moving & timeless film 🙂
LikeLike
le0pard13
/ January 25, 2013One of the most unexpectedly noirish, too.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013Oh yeah, been a long time since I’ve seen it, and it was surprisingly bleeker & darker than I remember! 🙂
LikeLike
Austin 'BishopReview'
/ January 25, 2013That Austin guy sure sounds swell. 😛
It was great reading this review, and I’ve already read it about 12 times! 😀
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013Ha ha, he is not a bad lad 🙂
Thank you, and for the opportunity to write about something which has no blood and torture, and it’s always nice to join in other projects. Appreciate it dude! 🙂
LikeLike
William Miller
/ January 25, 2013Excellent review. This is one of my all-time favorite films.
Nice work, Bill
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013Thanks very much Bill, appreciate it! This is one movie I’ve reviewed where I’m expecting most people to love it. Surely has to be one of everyones favourites, just simply a beautiful film 🙂
LikeLike
Kim @ Tranquil Dreams
/ January 25, 2013Awesome review, Tyson!
I’m a newcomer in the field of classics. I’m still working on seeing more of them. So I haven’t seen this one. Although my boyfriend does praise this movie a lot. I really have to find time to make a stop at the store to get some movies.. haha!
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013Thank you Kim!!
I would also class myself as a newcomer. Like you though, I’m trying!! I have just started recording them all on our MGM/Classics HD channel over here, and I want to try broaden my horizons! My worry reviewing them is doing them justice!
I just cant imagine people not loving this film. I hope you get to see it soon 🙂
LikeLike
Ryan
/ January 25, 2013Great review! You know, I’ve never seen this movie but it’s one that I hear about quite often — it being a classic and all. Are there any zombies in it? Because I just might need to watch it.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013Cheers Ryan!!
My wife’s exact words when she saw me watching it:
‘Didn’t think there would be enough deaths and torture for you’
🙂
It is excellent dude, and a little darker than many people would imagine. No zombies, but just a film that will make you happy 🙂 Give it a shot!
LikeLike
Teepee12
/ January 25, 2013Reblogged this on Serendipity and commented:
This is MY favorite Christmas movie. Love that “movie within a movie” alternate history thing. Enough like time travel to tickle my brain in all the right places and enough sentimentality to need at least a couple of kleenex.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Thanks again for the reblog Marilyn. Very clever approach with the journey back in time element. And yeah, I have to admit it made even me feel happy and emotional. Beautiful ending 🙂
LikeLike
My Heathen Heart
/ January 25, 2013So long since I’ve seen It’s A Wonderful Life – it never gets old.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013Exactly, just a timeless classic. I need to make more effort to see it again soon. It was too long in between viewings! 🙂
Thanks for stopping by 😛
LikeLike
My Heathen Heart
/ January 25, 2013My pleasure, and yes, it’s also been way too long between viewings for me, too, so thank you for the reminder 🙂
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013You’re welcome!! 🙂
LikeLike
Teepee12
/ January 25, 2013My favorite holiday movie. I like others too, but this one never gets old for me.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013For sure, just a perfect movie, I mean any time of the year would be ideal, but especially around Christmas makes it just that bit more special!
Thanks for the re-blog 🙂
LikeLike
Alastair
/ January 25, 2013I watched this for the first time on Christmas Eve. I watched the one that had redone in colour. It was bloody awesome.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013I know I said it had to be seen as intended, in black and white, but one day I will watch it in colour just to compare. I expect you to watch the b&w version in trade!
Cheers Alastair 🙂
LikeLike
Alastair
/ January 25, 2013I will do 🙂 Just to see how it compares.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013Nice one, report back with our findings alright!? 😉
LikeLike
Alastair
/ January 25, 2013Definitely
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013😛
LikeLike
gregory moss
/ January 25, 2013Can’t say I’ve ever seen this – or ever felt the need to. It plays here on the tele every christmas (why is that?).
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 25, 2013Really? You need to see and appreciate this Greg!! It even makes someone like me feel happy 🙂
It’s a Christmassy film, so maybe next time its on you could check it out? 😉
LikeLike
table9mutant
/ January 25, 2013Yeah! You’ve got to see it! I watch it pretty much every Christmas. Love it. 🙂 Great review!
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Cheers buddy!! 🙂
LikeLike
Garry Armstrong
/ January 26, 2013Jimmy Stewart’s first post war film. He showed flashes of his dark side that would become more obvious in his 50’s westerns directed by Anthony Mann. I think Stewart is one of the few stars from Hollywood’s “golden age” who actually got better as he aged.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Yeah in places he was pretty dark here, relatively speaking of course. Such a great screen presence though, I couldn’t take my eyes off him.
Cheers Garry 🙂
LikeLike
Sir Phobos
/ January 26, 2013My essential Christmas time movie is Bad Santa. That’s pretty similar to It’s a Wonderful Life, I think.
I haven’t watched this in forever, but I wouldn’t mind another go with it. Check this out, though, it’s pretty funny:
http://www.uproxx.com/gammasquad/2012/12/its-a-terrifying-life-three-reasons-the-christmas-classic-is-actually-a-horror-movie/
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Bad Santa is definitely similar……. 😉
I like the link, it actually has some valid points! They could definitely make an R rated version of Wonderful Life. Actually, thats what Bad Santa is 😉
LikeLike
Sir Phobos
/ January 26, 2013Yea, it’s a spiritual successor.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Joking aside, I do love Bad Santa!! 🙂
LikeLike
Sir Phobos
/ January 26, 2013Hell yes. It actually is on my yearly watch list. That movie will never, ever, ever get old. Ever.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Arent they doing a sequel, or a tv version of it? Swear I saw that talked about somewhere
LikeLike
Sir Phobos
/ January 26, 2013God, I hope not. A sequel could be good, but not a TV version.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Apparently Bad Santa 2 is a go, Billy Bob is back, the guy writing and directing it is from from Hot Tub Time Machine (which I liked)
LikeLike
Sir Phobos
/ January 26, 2013I still haven’t got around to seeing that, but it sounds like you think he’s a good match for this? I’m a little skeptical if it’s not the same guy who directed the first one.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Well, Hot Tub was crude and funny, so it’s sorta on the same wavelength for a start. The last bit of info for Bad Santa 2 was about 5 months ago. It has a page on IMDB, and lots of sites say whos attached and writing/directing, but no start date as of yet. Got to live in hope right!? 🙂
LikeLike
atothewr
/ January 26, 2013Great review of a great movie. A classic in every way possible.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Thanks buddy, and yeah, just about as perfect as a movie can get 🙂
LikeLike
wordschat
/ January 26, 2013Tyson, Jimmy Stewart is my fav actor of all time. Your review us a lovely tribute. You mention The Sopranos reference. Without cheating to IMDB how many other references can people pass along besides mine here?
1- Gremlins where the main street is called Bedford and there is a Building & Loan
2- Bruce Almighty where Jim Carey does a lasso the moon debit literally as he plays God
3- Glee where Chord Over street’s Sam character also does the lasso line in a black and white sequence.
Also when Georges uncle after they’re drinking goes off screen falls down to the sound of crashing cans and yells to George “I’m alright” well that’s an ad lib.A prop table fell over making the noise. The actor faked the line and Stewart ran with it. Thanks for bringing Christmas back a month after.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Apologies for the late reply. Very unfair that the spam collector would put you in there. 🙂
I honestly can’t think of any other references really, but the ones you mention are pretty cool! I’ll have to have a think about that one!
Loving the trivia, and sometimes mistakes/ad-libs etc make things better. I know of lots of occasions with stuff like that improving bits. Thanks for the kind words, and glad you approve of my review. Such a pleasure talking about a film like this, glad it has had such a positive reaction in here 🙂
LikeLike
wordschat
/ January 26, 2013My pleasure. The review made my day before going out in -20c with friends for dinner. Sleep tight.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013-20c? Wow, we go into a nationwide panic with a bit of snow and -2. Have fun! 🙂
LikeLike
Todd Benefiel
/ January 26, 2013Tyson, you mention that the film finishes with one of the most beautiful endings you’ve seen; I don’t know if you mean the bridge moment or the actual happy at-the-house wrap-up, but for me that moment on the bridge is my favorite, and always gets me: begging for Clarence’s help as he leans on the railing, full of despair and repeating “I want to live again”, his head down…and then the snow slowly begins to fall behind him, signaling that he’s back.
Oh hell, I’m getting misty just typing it…
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Yeah I think from the bridge onwards. Its going dark places, he is upset, begs for it all back at the bridge and then its just really sad and then really happy! Beautiful, and even though you know it will end happily, still a great last few minutes and I imagine a few people get a little misty….. 🙂
LikeLike
Mr Rumsey
/ January 26, 2013One of my favourite films, certainly my favourite Christmas film. Great review Tyson 😀
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Cheers buddy! A bit different to Die Hard which I tried arguing with people over it being a xmas movie. At least this is THE Christmas movie 🙂
LikeLike
Mr Rumsey
/ January 26, 2013Haha, I’m with you on Die Hard being a Christmas movie – the second best one, after It’s a Wonderful Life. 🙂
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Definitely, when I have kids I’m going to make them watch both, every Christmas. A cool routine I would say 🙂
LikeLike
Mr Rumsey
/ January 26, 2013Certainly, just wait a few years longer before you throw Gremlins in there as well! 😀
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Man who doesn’t love Gremlins!? 🙂
LikeLike
Mr Rumsey
/ January 26, 2013You have to be pretty odd to not love that film 😛
Still, I’m glad that I didn’t see it as a kid.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Ive mentioned on here before but I used to terrify my brother and tell him Gremlins were under his bed. Cruel to be kind, toughening him up!
LikeLike
Mr Rumsey
/ January 26, 2013Haha, of course! He clearly benefited from that process! 😀
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Exactly. Won’t sleep with the light off and he’s 25, but still….. 🙂
LikeLike
jeffro517
/ January 26, 2013I love this movie. I’m a huge fan of Stewart and this is one of the film I encourage everyone to see. It’s an amazing story that almost wasn’t a film. Thank goodness Capra believed in it. I reviewed this as part of my series on Stewart. Nice choice!
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 26, 2013Thanks very much!! 🙂
LikeLike
Terry Malloy's Pigeon Coop
/ January 27, 2013Great film, great review 🙂 Hanging on to those last little remnants of Christmas!
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 27, 2013Cheers buddy! Yeah, I was going to do it at xmas, but ran out of time, went with Elf & Home Alone, and now Austins project gave me a chance 🙂
LikeLike
fernandorafael
/ January 28, 2013Great post, Tyson! Stewart is my favorite actor and this is one of his best performances. Also, this is THE Christmas movie and I make it a priority to see it every year. That ending gets me EVERY TIME.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 28, 2013Thank you Fernando!
I am late to the party in appreciating his work, but I will strive to see more. He was incredible here. If the ending doesnt affect people, they cant be human!
Cheers buddy 🙂
LikeLike
sanclementejedi
/ January 28, 2013Not only one of my favorite Christmas films but one of my favorite films of all time. There is a great Saturday Night Live skit from the late 80’s where they show a deleted ending scene. At the films conclusion where everyone is singing, Uncle Billy recalls Old Man Potter has the cash. A mob heads over to his office and beats the tar out of him while singing. 😉
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 28, 2013I will have to look for that on YouTube, sounds great!! Cheers, and definitely one of the best films made. Should be one of everyones favourites 🙂
LikeLike
simon watson
/ January 30, 2013I think this one of the most depression films of all times
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ January 30, 2013Ive said it before, and Ill say it again; you have issues Simon 🙂
LikeLike
simon
/ January 31, 2013ok I will now say why I think this film is depressing. James Stewart dreams in this film are always being crushed. He never gets to begin his life of his choosing. Every time he tries some thing else pulls him down. In the end he tries to comment suicide why because its not a wonderful life when you a nice guy.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ February 1, 2013In a weird way I see your point. I still think by going through the tough times it makes the end even sweeter, and by seeing what life was like for everyone around him whose life he changed, made him realise how worthwhile his life has been. 🙂
LikeLike
jennypugh
/ February 7, 2013It’s A Wonderful Life is one of my favourite films and this is a great review 🙂
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ February 8, 2013Glad you love the film, should be one of everyone’s favourites. Thanks for the kind words! 🙂
LikeLike
Tom
/ April 8, 2013Unfortunately I belong to the category of those who have not seen It’s A Wonderful Life. But with this review behind me, I’m adding it to my list of Must-See’s. Great write up.
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ April 8, 2013Thanks Tom, appreciate that, and really hope you like it (Im sure you will!) 🙂
LikeLike
Jon Harrison
/ October 15, 2013Splendid review! I know you saw this ages ago now, but glad you got to see it!
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ October 15, 2013Thanks for checking out my site and review Jon! I’m glad I finally saw the movie, and will aim to watch it every year now after missing out for so long 🙂
LikeLike
Jon Harrison
/ October 15, 2013Yes indeed, I’m digging it! Haha have to force myself to get off the computer and sleep. That sounds like a great idea haha
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ October 15, 2013Nice, enjoying your site too, glad I found it! 🙂
LikeLike
Jon Harrison
/ October 15, 2013Cheers! 😀
LikeLike
Ayush Chandra
/ June 29, 2014You did a great review, it’s really a hard job to review a classic film…
LikeLike
Tyson Carter
/ July 5, 2014Thanks for the kind words 🙂
LikeLike